November 2026     Edition 194
If Dogs Could Teach Critical Thinking
Announcements

Next Critical Thinking Open Enrollment   One day workshop in two half days,
June 28/29
Follow us on Linkedin and Twitter
My home is dogless at the moment, but remembering some of what my previous dogs did, and for all dog owners, much of this will be familiar. Every afternoon, my dog used to walk over to the living room window, stare intensely at an empty patch of grass, tilt his head forty-five degrees, and appear to think deeply before deciding whether a blowing leaf warrants a full-scale security alert.


Watching my dog process invisible data while I was focused in back-to-back online status meetings made me wonder: if a dog could talk about critical thinking, what advice would he give us and how would dog advice translate to human advice?


I imagine he’d wag his tail, rest his chin on my knee, and say something like this:


"I’ve spent the last eight years lying under your desk while you stare at glowing rectangles, sigh at spreadsheets, and attend endless meetings that could have been just a few barks. After observing you all for this long, here are 17 things I’ve learned about critical thinking."



  • Always sniff the bush before you mark it.

    Translation: Gather your own data before claiming territory.



  • The loudest bark in the neighborhood usually belongs to the smallest dog.

    Translation: Volume is not authority.



  • If the ball didn’t leave a human’s hand, don’t sprint across the yard.

    Translation: Watch actual execution, not the fake-out.



  • Just because the squirrel ran up the tree doesn’t mean it’s still in the tree.

    Translation: Update your assumptions when the situation changes.



  • When three dogs start barking down the street, check the yard before joining the chorus.

    Translation: Social noise is often just contagious panic.



  • Just because you found a meatball under the dining table once doesn’t mean it’s a magic meatball table.

     
    Translation: Never confuse a lucky anomaly with a repeatable strategy.



  • If you chase your own tail long enough, you’ll feel very busy and go nowhere

    . Translation: Motion is not progress.



  • The vacuum cleaner makes a terrifying noise, yet it has never once eaten anybody.

    Translation: Separate loud distractions from actual threats.



  • Never assume a hand behind someone’s back is holding a treat.

    Translation: Verify what you can’t see before celebrating.



  • The cat looks calm because the cat is lying.

    Translation: Never mistake composure for competence.



  • You don’t need to destroy the entire shoe to realize it isn’t food.

    Translation: Test your assumptions early before causing irreversible damage.



  • Tilting your head doesn’t change the facts, but it helps you hear them better.

    Translation: A slight shift in perspective solves half the confusion.



  • If you’re digging a hole and hit concrete, stop digging

    .
    Translation: Effort will not turn a bad premise into a good outcome.



  • Trust your nose over your eyes.

    Translation: Packaging is designed to fool you; investigate what’s actually inside.



  • Correlation is not causation.

    Every morning I bark at the garbage truck, and every morning it drives away.  I wonder if I’m that powerful.  Translation: Just because events appear related doesn’t make it so.



  • A leash isn’t always a punishment; sometimes it’s the only thing keeping you out of traffic.

    Translation: Guardrails exist to protect you while you figure out where you’re going.



  • When in doubt, drop the stick and look around.

    Translation: You can’t pick up a better opportunity if your jaws are clamped shut on an old one.




One last thing…and the Takeaway:


You humans spend a lot of energy trying to look like the smartest creature in the room. From down here under the desk, critical thinking looks much simpler: stay curious, check the facts with your own nose, and never be too proud to admit you just spent ten minutes barking at a plastic bag blowing in the wind. Translation: Ask questions, verify your information, and don’t stay the course with a bad idea.


If you like this edition,

click here to get a Free Subscription to The Headscratcher Post.

  A monthly post with tips and techniques about problem solving, creativity, innovation and critical thinking.

PLACE HOLDER
Think Smarter Book Image

Check out our Workshops

• Critical Thinking for Problem Solving and Decision Making (Core, Core+Advanced)
• Advanced Critical Thinking and Innovation
• Advanced Critical Thinking and Decision Making
• Critical Thinking for Supervisors, Managers and Leaders

Visit us at www.headscratchers.com


If you're not already a subscriber to The HeadScratcher Post,
Signup Here

Previous versions of The HeadScratcher Post
HeadScratchers

Critical Thinking Techniques for Problem Solving, Decision Making, Innovation and Leadership.
Our Mission;

To help people become better HeadScratchers! We teach critical thinking techniques to managers, leaders and individuals resulting in the improved performance of an individual and organization.